Responding to Pro-gay Social Arguments (Part One)

September 1, 2005

by Joe Dallas

Social justice argument #1: 'Homosexuality is inborn.'

Social justice arguments are effective because they sound so good. They demand an end to homophobia and insensitivity; who wants to say they are against such goals? But just as the question “When did you stop beating your wife, Mr. Jones?” assumes (without proof) that Mr. Jones has been beating his wife, so the pro-gay social justice arguments assume (without proof) that gays are victims, and that the conservative church is largely responsible for their victimhood.